IPsec with public key authentication

Stop using pre-shared keys!

Pre-shared keys suck, because reasons

  • The key must be kept secret, which means it must be shared only over a secure channel e.g. PGP, face-to-face
  • Most implementations will accept insecure (too short, too simple) keys
  • The insecure IKE aggressive mode must be used to support distinct PSKs for multiple dynamic peers, or
  • All dynamic peers must use the same PSK in order to use the more secure IKE main mode

Public keys are better

  • They can be transmitted over insecure channels without compromising security
  • No need to generate a new key for each connection; just send the same public key to each new peer
  • Most implementations generate keys using high quality random numbers by default; one must try to generate an insecure key
  • Dynamic peers can all have distinct public keys and still use IKE main mode

So why isn't everyone using public keys already?

  • The various IKE implementations don't all use the same format to represent public keys (but we can easily convert between them)
  • Documentation on how to, and why you should, configure public keys instead of PSKs is lacking (which is why this page exists)
  • Some implementations don't expose the ability to use public keys directly, only allowing a choice between PSKs and X.509 certificates

Public keys means certificates, right? Certificates are hard :(

Many IKE implementations support manually configuring trusted public keys, without having to create a CA, generate CSRs, sign certificates, or remember/look up the commands to do those things.

Keep in mind that certificates are just public keys wrapped with some extra metadata so that your router can automatically verify that it belongs to someone you trust. Certificates are useful for instances where there are so many peers that it's infeasible to manually configure each one's public key, such as a "road warrior" configuration or DMVPN. In those scenarios it makes sense to set up a Certificate Authority to handle it.

Ok fine, how do I public key?

Conversion tool

Different implementations use different formats to represent public keys, and it's necessary to be able to convert between them. Here is a script for that purpose:

https://git.dn42.us/ryan/pubkey-converter/raw/master/pubkey-converter.pl

How-To examples

Implementation Key format
strongSwan >= 5.0.0 PEM
Cisco IOS Hexadecimal DER
Mikrotik RouterOS PEM
OpenBSD PEM
Racoon Base64 RFC 3110
strongSwan < 5.0.0 Base64 RFC 3110
VyOS/EdgeOS Base64 RFC 3110

Notes

  1. Best practice is to generate the private key on the router itself, and not transfer it to another machine. This part should be kept secret!
  2. Generate a key of at least 2048 bits, preferably 4096 if both ends support it.
  3. Some implementations support more than one key format. The examples here only show how to use one of them (usually PEM) for brevity.
  4. RFC 3110 format is the same as that described in RFC 2537. The former obsoletes the latter.